Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Vizey's avatar

Man, this blog is great but these commenters leave something to be desired. Keep up the good work, James!

Expand full comment
David Holzman's avatar

This substack writer obviously knows nothing about the environment. You can't keep increasing the population and expect the environment to function properly. We depend on something called "ecosystem services" which I learned about in 1975, along with global warming, from the professor who would become President Obama's SCience Advisor. Ecosystem services provide clean water, clean air, fertile soil, disease prevention, building materials (lumber), pollination, and so much more. But they depend on healthy, intact ecosystems. A suburb with lawns does not qualify, nor does agricultural land, or land that has been logged. The rise of tick-borne diseases is due to encroachment of human activity into heretofore intact ecosystems.

The reduction of the Chinese birthrate is terrific news for that country and for the world. And the US needs to greatly reduce immigration. ***Too much*** immigration is the thing that has done the most to keep Blacks, and more recently poor whites and recent immigrants down in the US. A new book makes a powerful case for that: Back of the Hiring Line: A 200-year History of Immigration Surges, Employer Bias, and Depression of Black Wealth. ($9 on Amazon).

During times of low immigration, Blacks have always begun to prosper. High immigrationโ€”always abetted by the cheap labor lobbies--has always pushed them back down again.

The current surge became particularly damaging in the early โ€˜90s, when the annual numbers passed 1 million.

Beck is thorough. The book draws heavily on academic research into economic history, publications run by Black people, statements of black leaders beginning with Frederick Douglass, and the determinations of multiple gov't commissions on immigration, all of which warned that mass immigration would take jobs from low/no-skilled Americans.

Had the US followed the recomendatations of these commissions, I suspect that the US never would have attained among the highest levels of inequality among the western industrialized nations.

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts